Failed DIY Waterproofing System Recovery
The Challenge
After watching YouTube videos and buying $3,500 in materials from Home Depot, this Scarborough homeowner attempted DIY waterproofing over two summers (2022-2023). The improper installation not only failed to stop water but created new problems: trapped water accelerated deterioration, improper slope caused pooling, and hydraulic cement patches redirected water to previously dry areas. By March 2024, the basement had worse flooding than before the DIY attempt, with structural concerns emerging.
Foundation crack exacerbated by improper DIY waterproofing attempts
Property Details
Home Specifications
- Built: 1968
- Foundation: Poured concrete, 8" walls
- Basement: 1,100 sq ft (partially finished)
- Soil Type: Heavy clay
- Water Table: High (near Highland Creek)
- Previous Issues: Minor seepage (2021)
- DIY Investment: $3,500 + 200 hours labor
DIY Attempts Made
- • Hydraulic cement on 12 cracks
- • Waterproof paint on all walls
- • Plastic sheeting vapor barrier
- • Hardware store sump pump kit
- • Exterior foundation coating (partial)
- • DIY French drain (improper slope)
- • Flex Seal on window wells
What Went Wrong: DIY Failure Analysis
Wet basement walls - the result of failed DIY waterproofing that made the problem worse
Critical DIY Mistakes Discovered:
- Hydraulic Cement Disaster: Applied to wet, active leaks without proper preparation. Created dams that redirected water to new areas. Trapped water behind caused concrete spalling. 8 of 12 patches had failed completely.
- Waterproof Paint Trap: Sealed moisture inside concrete walls. Paint bubbled and peeled, creating pockets where water accumulated. Prevented walls from breathing, accelerating deterioration.
- Vapor Barrier Nightmare: 6-mil plastic stapled directly to walls trapped moisture, creating perfect mold environment. Water ran down behind plastic, pooling at floor. Black mold grew extensively behind barrier.
- Sump Pump Errors: Pit too shallow (18" instead of 24"). Pump undersized (1/4 HP for high water table). No check valve installed - water flowed back. Discharged only 6 feet from foundation.
- French Drain Failure: Installed with NEGATIVE slope in two sections. Used corrugated pipe that collapsed. No filter fabric - clogged with mud. Created water collection points instead of drainage.
- Exterior Coating Mistake: Applied waterproofing over wet, dirty surface. Only did accessible areas (40% coverage). Product was driveway sealer, not foundation coating. Peeled off within months.
Net Result: Water problems increased 300%. New cracks formed from hydrostatic pressure. Mold remediation required. Total damage: $12,000 beyond DIY costs.
Our Professional Remediation
Professional basement water leak inspection - the critical first step in proper remediation
Phase 1: Damage Control & Removal (Day 1)
- • Remove all failed DIY materials (paint, plastic, patches)
- • Mold remediation on affected areas (HEPA filtration)
- • Chip out failed hydraulic cement patches
- • Remove collapsed DIY drainage system
- • Extract DIY sump pump and undersized pit
- • Document damage for insurance purposes
Phase 2: Foundation Repair (Days 2-3)
- • Properly prepare and inject 12 original cracks with polyurethane
- • Inject 5 new cracks caused by trapped water pressure
- • Repair spalled concrete from freeze-thaw damage
- • Grind smooth all surface irregularities
- • Apply crystalline waterproofing to entire interior
- • Install proper vapor barrier with drainage channels
Phase 3: Interior Drainage System (Days 4-5)
- • Jackhammer perimeter for proper drainage installation
- • Install WaterGuard® system (110 linear feet)
- • Ensure proper slope (1/8" per foot minimum)
- • Install inspection ports for maintenance
- • Connect to properly sized sump pit (22" x 30" deep)
- • Place filter fabric and gravel as specified
Phase 4: Sump Pump System (Day 5)
- • Install 1/2 HP primary pump (proper size for water table)
- • Add battery backup system (failed DIY had none)
- • Install check valve and silent check valve
- • Run 2" discharge line with freeze protection
- • Discharge 15 feet from foundation with pop-up valve
- • Install water alarm and pump monitoring
Phase 5: Exterior Corrections (Day 6)
- • Excavate problem corner where DIY coating failed
- • Apply proper rubberized membrane (600 sq ft)
- • Install dimple drainage board
- • Correct grading around entire home
- • Extend downspouts 10 feet from foundation
- • Install window well drains and covers
DIY vs Professional Comparison
| Aspect | DIY Attempt | Professional Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Crack Repair | Hydraulic cement (failed) | Polyurethane injection |
| Drainage Slope | Negative slope (pooling) | 1/8" per foot |
| Sump Pump Size | 1/4 HP (undersized) | 1/2 HP + backup |
| Pit Depth | 18 inches | 30 inches |
| Discharge Distance | 6 feet | 15 feet |
| Vapor Barrier | Plastic sheeting (trapped moisture) | Drainage mat system |
| Wall Treatment | Paint (sealed in water) | Crystalline (breathable) |
| Result | 300% worse flooding | 100% dry |
Cost Analysis
Financial Impact Breakdown:
DIY Attempt Costs:
- Materials from Home Depot: $3,500
- Tool rental/purchase: $800
- 200 hours labor (valued at $30/hr): $6,000
- Water damage from failures: $12,000
- Mold remediation required: $3,000
- Total DIY Loss: $25,300
Professional Remediation:
- Removal of DIY materials: $1,500
- Crack injection (17 total): $2,800
- Interior drainage system: $4,400
- Proper sump system: $2,800
- Exterior corrections: $3,500
- Concrete restoration: $1,200
- Mold remediation: $2,800
- Total Professional: $19,000
Total Cost to Homeowner: $44,300 ($25,300 DIY loss + $19,000 professional fix)
If Done Right Initially: ~$15,000 (would have saved $29,300)
Results After Professional Remediation
Immediate Results (First 30 Days)
- Complete elimination of water infiltration
- Humidity dropped from 78% to 45%
- Sump pump cycling properly (not constantly)
- No water accumulation anywhere
- Mold remediation successful
8-Month Follow-Up (November 2024)
- Survived spring thaw and summer storms perfectly
- No crack re-opening or new cracks
- Battery backup activated during 2 power outages
- Basement refinished successfully ($22,000)
- Insurance rates reduced with professional certificate
Common DIY Mistakes to Avoid
Top 10 DIY Waterproofing Failures We See:
- Using hydraulic cement on active leaks - Creates dams, redirects water
- Waterproof paint on wet walls - Traps moisture, causes spalling
- Improper drainage slope - Water pools instead of draining
- Undersized sump pumps - Can't handle water volume
- No check valves - Water flows back into pit
- Plastic vapor barriers - Create mold factories
- Partial solutions - Water finds new paths
- Wrong materials - Driveway sealer ≠ foundation waterproofing
- Ignoring building codes - Creates liability issues
- No permits pulled - Insurance may deny claims
Remember: Water always wins. It will find or create new paths if not properly managed.
Homeowner's Hard-Learned Lesson
"I'm an engineer and pretty handy, so I thought I could handle waterproofing myself. I watched every YouTube video, read forums, bought quality materials. But water doesn't care about your confidence - it follows physics. My DIY attempts made things so much worse. The hydraulic cement created new leaks, the paint trapped water causing concrete damage, and my drainage system became a water collection system. After two years of fighting and failing, calling Dryspace was humbling but necessary. They fixed my mistakes and did it right. The $44,000 total cost hurts, but the lesson is invaluable: waterproofing isn't a DIY job. It requires experience, proper equipment, and understanding of water behavior that YouTube can't teach. My advice? Call professionals first. Your ego and wallet will thank you."
Why DIY Waterproofing Usually Fails
Technical Challenges:
- • Requires understanding of hydrostatic pressure
- • Need to identify water source (not just symptom)
- • Proper slope calculations critical
- • Material compatibility knowledge essential
- • Building code requirements complex
- • Soil conditions affect approach
Equipment/Experience Gaps:
- • Professional injection pumps needed
- • Proper concrete cutting equipment
- • Years to understand water behavior
- • Knowledge of multiple solutions
- • Experience with unexpected issues
- • Access to commercial-grade materials
Success Rate Statistics:
DIY Waterproofing: 15% long-term success
Professional Installation: 95% long-term success
DIY failures cost 2-3x more to fix than original professional installation
Considering DIY? Get a Free Consultation First
Before you invest time and money in DIY waterproofing, let us provide a professional assessment and quote. Many homeowners are surprised that professional installation costs less than their planned DIY budget - and comes with a lifetime warranty.
Average DIY attempt: $3,500 materials + 200 hours labor
Professional installation: Often comparable or less, with warranty
Related Services & Resources
Foundation Crack Repair
Professional crack injection and repair using proper polyurethane techniques to prevent DIY failures.
Learn More →Concrete Repair
Repair spalled and damaged concrete caused by improper waterproofing and trapped moisture.
Learn More →Emergency Waterproofing
Emergency water damage control and temporary waterproofing solutions for immediate flooding issues.
Learn More →Get Your Free Inspection
Schedule your comprehensive basement inspection today. Our certified experts will assess your needs and provide a detailed solution.
Quick Response
Same-day inspections available
No Obligation
Free inspection & quote
Expert Analysis
25+ years of experience
Direct Contact
Business Hours
24/7 Emergency Service Available